Start With What Each Set Actually Includes
The fastest way to choose between FunnyPlaying, eXtremeRate and stock-style GBA buttons is to check the parts list against your build. A set that includes membranes or shrapnel can save you a separate order, while a set that leaves them out may cost less up front but needs extra parts. The three sets below differ most in what comes in the bag and how they are intended to fit.
What Comes in Each Button Set
- Game Boy Advance Buttons - Funnyplaying: FunnyPlaying set includes 1 D-pad, A and B buttons, power switch cover, left and right triggers, left and right bumpers, and 2 LR shrapnel. This is a broad kit that covers the main buttons and the metal trigger pieces, so you can plan around fewer separate parts.

Game Boy Advance Buttons - Funnyplaying - Game Boy Advance Buttons - eXtremeRate: eXtremeRate set includes A and B buttons, D-pad, triggers, bumpers, power button, select and start pieces, and a clear membrane set, but LED cover and L/R shrapnel are not included. The included start/select membranes are useful, but you will need to source shrapnel and an LED cover separately if your build needs them.

Game Boy Advance Buttons - eXtremeRate - Game Boy Advance Buttons: Stock-style set includes A and B buttons, R and L triggers, D-pad, R and L bumpers, and power switch, but no LED cover piece. This is the leanest kit of the three, so check whether you already have membranes and an LED cover before ordering.
Materials and Finish: ABS Plastic in Different Forms
All three sets use ABS plastic, but the finish and color options vary. FunnyPlaying and the stock-style set offer many solid and clear colors. eXtremeRate adds soft-touch matte finishes and chameleon color-shifting variants. None of the supplied records list hardness or texture measurements, so feel is best judged by the finish description rather than a spec sheet.
Finish and Color Options That Affect Feel
- Game Boy Advance Buttons - Funnyplaying: FunnyPlaying buttons are high-quality ABS plastic with many color options, including clear and solid colors. Color choice is broad, but the record does not describe a soft-touch or matte finish, so expect a standard plastic feel.
- Game Boy Advance Buttons - eXtremeRate: eXtremeRate soft-touch variants have a matte, soft texture, anti-slip finish; chameleon variants change color. If grip and a non-glossy surface matter to you, the soft-touch line is the clearest differentiator in this comparison.
- Game Boy Advance Buttons: Stock-style buttons are injection-molded ABS plastic in many colors. This is the most conventional option, with color variety but no special finish claims in the supplied information.
Shell Fit: Aftermarket vs Original Shells
Fit is where these sets diverge most. FunnyPlaying states its buttons are compatible with OEM and aftermarket shells but work best with FunnyPlaying shells. eXtremeRate and the stock-style set both note they are better suited to aftermarket shells, with possible fitting issues in original shells. If you are keeping your original shell, plan for extra clearances or choose a set with the broadest stated compatibility.
Compatibility Notes You Should Read Before Buying
- Game Boy Advance Buttons - Funnyplaying: Compatible with OEM and aftermarket shells, however, these work best when paired with FunnyPlaying shells. This is the only set in the comparison with an explicit OEM compatibility statement, though the best fit is still with matching FunnyPlaying shells.
- Game Boy Advance Buttons - eXtremeRate: Better suited for aftermarket shells; fitting issues may occur in original OEM shells. If you are set on an original shell, expect to test fit and possibly adjust.
- Game Boy Advance Buttons: Better suited for aftermarket shells; fitting issues may occur in original OEM shells. Same caveat as eXtremeRate: aftermarket shells are the safer pairing.
Feel and Practical Trade-offs
Aftermarket buttons may not feel identical to genuine parts; FunnyPlaying states this directly. The eXtremeRate set includes custom silicone membranes for start and select, which may change the feel of those buttons compared with reusing old membranes. The stock-style set does not include membranes in the supplied list, so you will pair it with your own. None of the records provide actuation force or travel specs, so feel remains a personal judgment based on materials and included parts.
Which Set Fits Your Build?
- Choose FunnyPlaying if you want a complete kit with shrapnel and OEM shell compatibility.: It includes the D-pad, A/B, power cover, triggers, bumpers and LR shrapnel, and is stated to work with OEM and aftermarket shells, with best results in FunnyPlaying shells.
- Choose eXtremeRate if you want soft-touch or chameleon finishes and included start/select membranes.: The set includes a clear membrane set and offers matte soft-touch and color-changing variants, but you must supply LED cover and L/R shrapnel separately and it is intended for aftermarket shells.
- Choose the stock-style set if you want a simple, lower-cost button refresh and already have membranes.: It covers the main buttons and power switch but omits the LED cover and does not list membranes, and it is best suited to aftermarket shells.




